Page 238 - Computational Statistics Handbook with MATLAB
P. 238

Chapter 6: Monte Carlo Methods for Inferential Statistics       225


                                7. The lower endpoint of the interval is given by the bootstrap repli-
                                   cate that is in the  B α 2⁄⋅  -th position of the ordered  θ ˆ *b  , and the
                                   upper endpoint is given  by the bootstrap replicate that is in  the
                                           ⁄
                                     ⋅
                                   B ( 1 –  α 2)  -th position of the same ordered list. Alternatively,
                                   using quantile notation, the lower endpoint is the estimated quan-
                                   tile  q ˆ  α 2   and the upper endpoint is the estimated quantile  q ˆ  1 –  α 2  ,
                                                                                           ⁄
                                        ⁄
                                   where the estimates are taken from the bootstrap replicates.
                             Example 6.12
                             Let’s find the bootstrap percentile interval for the same forearm data. The
                             confidence interval is easily found from the bootstrap replicates, as shown
                             below.
                                % Use Statistics Toolbox function
                                % to get the bootstrap replicates.
                                bvals = bootstrp(B,'mom',forearm);
                                % Find the upper and lower endpoints
                                k = B*alpha/2;
                                sbval = sort(bvals);
                                blo = sbval(k);
                                bhi = sbval(B-k);
                             This interval is given by  1.03 1.45,(  )  , which is slightly narrower than the
                             bootstrap-t interval from Example 6.11.


                              So far, we discussed three types of bootstrap confidence intervals. The stan-
                                                                     θ
                                                                     ˆ
                             dard interval is the easiest and assumes that   is normally distributed. The
                                                                                 θ
                                                                                 ˆ
                             bootstrap-t interval estimates the standardized version of   from the data,
                             avoiding the normality assumptions used in the standard interval. The per-
                             centile interval is simple to calculate and obtains the endpoints directly from
                                                                     ˆ
                             the bootstrap estimate of the distribution for θ.  It has another advantage in
                                                                                   θ
                             that it is range-preserving. This means that if the parameter   can take on
                             values in a certain range, then the confidence interval will reflect that. This is
                             not always the case with the other intervals.
                              According to Efron and Tibshirani [1993], the bootstrap-t interval has good
                             coverage probabilities, but does not perform well in practice. The bootstrap
                             percentile interval is more dependable in most situations, but does not enjoy
                             the good coverage property of the bootstrap-t interval. There is another boot-
                                                                  interval, that has both good cover-
                             strap confidence interval, called the  BC a
                             age and is dependable. This interval is described in the next chapter.
                              The bootstrap estimates of bias and standard error are also random vari-
                             ables, and they have their own error associated with them. So, how accurate
                             are they? In the next chapter, we discuss how one can use the jackknife
                             method to evaluate the error in the bootstrap estimates.
                              As with any method, the bootstrap is not appropriate in every situation.
                             When analytical methods are available to understand the uncertainty associ-



                             © 2002 by Chapman & Hall/CRC
   233   234   235   236   237   238   239   240   241   242   243