Page 210 - The ISA Handbook in Contemporary Sociology

9781412934633-Chap-12 1/10/09 8:48 AM Page 181

SITES OF CONFLICT AND COLLABORATION 181

Studies of art controversies provide insights collaborations shape and are shaped by the
that are relevant for other research areas in new dynamics of art, money and power in
sociology, among them: sociology of organi- contemporary society.
zations, sociology of work and occupations,
research methodology, sociological theory and
political sociology. For example, they provide
opportunities for understanding disputes in REFERENCES
other areas. In research about forms of justifi-
Anonymous (1993a) Cartoon captioned ‘But is
cations used by opponents with irreconcilable
it Art Criticism?’, Daily Telegraph. November
differences in various types of disputes, Luc
25: 21.
Boltanski and Laurent Thévenot (1991) pro-
Anonymous (1993b) ‘The K Foundation ...’,
posed a typology of appeals to higher author-
Melody Maker, September 11, n.p. Turner
ity used to justify positions (such as political Prize Press Clippings, Tate Gallery Archives.
philosophies of civic worth or market worth). Anonymous (1993c) ‘The K Foundation ...’,
The trick, of course, for competitors is to New Music Express. September 11: 2.
arrange the hierarchy of justice in such a way Anonymous (1993d) ‘Rachel’s House Floors
that one’s own set of criteria prevails. Critics’, The Yorkshire Evening Press.
Justifications based on the market place are November 24, n.p. Turner Prize Press
only one element in public debates about Clippings, Tate Gallery Archives.
Adorno, Theodor (1962) ‘Types of Musical
art but economic issues often surface in con-
Conduct’, Introduction to the Sociology of
troversies. Boltanski and Chiapello (1999)
Music. NY: Seabury Press. pp. 1–20.
developed a theory about the ‘new spirit of
Alexander, Victoria (2003) Sociology of the Arts:
capitalism’ that identified changing attitudes
Exploring Fine and Popular Forms. London:
towards money in civil society. They adopt a Palgrave Macmillan.
minimalist notion of capitalism as a cycle of Balfe, Judith (ed.) (1993) Paying the Piper:
conversion of capital into goods and then back Causes and Consequences of Art Patronage.
into capital resulting in an unlimited accumu- Chicago: University of Illinois Press.
lation of wealth premised on consumption. Barnes, Barry and Bloor, David (1982) ‘Relativism,
This neo-capitalist ideology justifies commit- Rationalism, and the Sociology of Knowledge’, in
ment to economic goals and profit-making Martin Hollis and Steven Lukes (eds.) Rationality
and Relativism. Oxford: B. Blackwell. pp. 21–47.
becomes a moral imperative. Profit-making is
Becker, H. (1982) Art Worlds. Berkeley:
considered ‘desirable, interesting, exciting,
University California Press.
innovative or meritorious’ with dire conse-
Becker, H. (2005) Howie’s Home Page
quences for the poor and for public welfare
http://home.earthlink.net/~hsbecker/) last
more generally (Chiapello, 1999: 95). Social accessed July 2005.
inequalities escalate, inducing a generalized Bennett, Tony (2000 [1995]) The Birth of the
political nihilism. Museum: History, Theory, Politics. London
If we reconsider the case studies of contro- and NY: Routledge.
versies presented in this chapter from this Boltanski, Luc and Chiapello, Ève (1999) Le
perspective, acceptance of the open interven- Nouvel Esprit du Capitalisme. Paris: Gallimard.
tion of economic forces in art worlds may be Boltanski, Luc and Thévenot, Laurent (1991) De
la Justification. Les Économies de la
seen as a manifestation of neo-capitalist logic
grandeur. Paris: Gallimard.
with profound implications for the study of
Bourdieu, Pierre (1984) Distinction: A Social
broader socio-political trends. Sociological
Critique of the Judgment of Taste.
research on art controversies has the poten-
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
tial to provide insights into how groups nego- Bourdieu, Pierre (1993) ‘Principles for a
tiate authority and arrive at a sense of justice Sociology of Cultural Works’, in P. Bourdieu
in a changing world, helping us to better (ed.) The Field of Cultural Production. NY:
understand ways in which conflicts and Columbia University Press. pp. 176–91.