Page 218 - Cultural Studies Dictionary
P. 218

SURVEILLANCE



              simply a negative mechanism of control but is productive of the self. The disciplinary
              power of schools, work organizations, prisons, hospitals, asylums and the
              proliferating discourses of sexuality produce subjectivity by bringing individuals
              into view. They achieve this by categorizing, naming and fixing subjects in writing  195
              via the discourses of, for example, medicine.
                 Foucault’s account of subjectivity has been of concern to a number of cultural
              writers because it appears to rob subjects of agency. Thus, if subjects are docile
              bodies generated by discursive practices then how can we conceive of persons as
              able to act since subjects appear to be ‘products’ rather than ‘producers’. However,
              agency can be said to be a subject position within discourse, that is, the capacity for
              agency is discursively determined and as such is best understood as the socially
              constructed capacity to act.
                 Foucault attacks what he calls the ‘great myth of the interior’ and adopts an anti-
              essentialist position in which the subject is not unified but fractured. The
              Enlightenment or Cartesian subject as understood through the work of Descartes
              has grasped persons as unique unified agents endowed with the capacities of reason,
              consciousness and action. Thus Descartes’ formulation ‘I think, therefore I am’
              places the rational, conscious individual subject at the heart of Western philosophy.
              By contrast the so-called fractured or postmodern subject conceives of the subject
              in terms of discursively constructed shifting, fragmented and multiple identities.
              Persons are composed not of one but of several, sometimes contradictory, identities
              because they have been subjected to and formed as subjects by a variety of
              discourses located in a range of social spaces. If we feel that we have a single identity
              it is because we have constructed a unifying narrative of the self.
              Links Agency, discourse, identity, self-identity, structuration, subject position

           Surveillance The process of surveillance involves the monitoring and collection of
              information about subject populations with an eye to the supervision and
              regulation of activities. Thus the idea of surveillance refers to the collection, storage
              and retrieval of information as well as to the direct supervision of activities and the
              use of information to monitor subject populations. It is widely argued that while
              modernity did not invent surveillance per se it did introduce new, more complex
              and extensive forms of surveillance. These included shifts from personal to
              impersonal control as marked by the bureaucratization, rationalization and
              professionalization that form the core institutional configurations of modernity.
                 In particular, the rise of modernity is associated with organizations intrinsic to
              which are attempts to regularize control of social relations across time and space.
              For example, the emergence of the industrial labour process included an increase in
              the size and division of labour in tandem with the mechanization and
              intensification of work. The workshop and factory were then utilized as a means of
              exerting discipline and the creation of new work habits. That is, they marked new
              forms of surveillance.
                 In the current period increased social and institutional reflexivity is manifested
              in the desire of institutions to know more about their workforce, customers and
   213   214   215   216   217   218   219   220   221   222   223