Page 195 - Materials Chemistry, Second Edition

9.4 Case study 193
TABLE 9.6 The decision-making matrix for worst alternative comparison—cont’d
DM1 Environmentalist DM2 Top manager
Storage container (WI,H) (0.56, Storage container (WI,H) (0.56,
0.84, 1.26) 0.84, 1.26)
CO 2 costs (EI,VH) (1, 1, 1) CO 2 costs (EI,VH) (1, 1, 1)
Total cost (VI,H) (2.1, 2.52, Total cost (VI,H) (2.1, 2.52,
2.94) 2.94)
Total cost without (FI,L) (0.82, 1.1, Total cost without (FI,L) (0.82, 1.1,
CO 2 1.37) CO 2 1.37)
Contribution to economic development Children’s
environmental
education
Social Total employees (FI,H) (1.26, Total employees (FI,M) (1.07,
1.68, 2.1) 1.42, 1.78)
Total working hours (FI,M) (1.07, Total working hours (FI,M) (1.07,
1.42, 1.78) 1.42, 1.78)
Total employees (VI,L) (1.37, Total employees (WI,L) (0.37,
with disabilities 1.64, 1.92) with disabilities 0.55, 0.82)
Total employees (FI,M) (1.07, Total employees (WI,L) (0.37,
with higher 1.42, 1.78) with higher 0.55, 0.82)
education education
Total employees (FI,H) (1.26, Total employees (WI,L) (0.37,
with basic education 1.68, 2.1) with basic education 0.55, 0.82)
Equal opportunities (FI,M) (1.07, Equal opportunities (WI,L) (0.37,
(sex) 1.42, 1.78) (sex) 0.55, 0.82)
Equal opportunities (VI,L) (1.37, Equal opportunities (WI,L) (0.37,
(disabilities) 1.64, 1.92) (disabilities) 0.55, 0.82)
Children’s (AI,H) (2.94, Children’s (EI,VH) (1, 1, 1)
environmental 3.36, 3.78) environmental
education education
Local employment (VI,L) (1.37, Local employment (VI,M) (1.78,
1.64, 1.92) 2.13, 2.49)
Public (VI,M) (1.78, Public (AI,H) (2.94,
commitments to 2.13, 2.49) commitments to 3.36, 3.78)
sustainability issues sustainability issues
Contribution to (EI,VH) (1, 1, 1) Contribution to (AI,VH) (3.33, 3.8,
economic economic 4.28)
development development
Note: AD, abiotic depletion; AC, acidification; EU, eutrophication; GW, global warming; OPD, ozone layer depletion; HT, human toxicity; WAE,
freshwater aquatic ecotoxicity; MAE, marine aquatic ecotoxicity; TE, terrestrial ecotoxicity; PO, photochemical oxidation; ED, energy
consumption.