Page 308 - Design and Operation of Heat Exchangers and their Networks

294 Design and operation of heat exchangers and their networks

Example H4C5—cont’d

Total annual cost ($/yr)
Solutions in the literature Reported Revised

Pettersson (2005) 2,904,953 2,892,924
Pava ˜o et al. (2017a) 2,919,154 2,919,112
Toffolo (2009) 2,919,684 2,919,675
Pava ˜o et al. (2017b) 2,919,675 2,919,676
Pava ˜o et al. (2017b) a 2,920,763 2,920,747
Huo et al. (2013) 2,922,600 2,920,516
Luo et al. (2009) 2,922,298 2,922,298
Huo et al. (2012) 2,925,634 2,923,265
Xiao et al. (2018) a 2,927,431 2,926,657
Pava ˜o et al. (2017c) a 2,928,629 2,927,797
Lewin (1998) 2,938,000 b 2,930,170
Bergamini et al. (2007) a 2,935,020 2,932,911
Nu ´n ˜ez-Serna and Zamora (2016) a 2,932,817
Peng and Cui (2015) a 2,935,000 2,933,023
a
Huo et al. (2013) 2,936,000 2,935,385
Yan et al. (2009) a 2,943,000 2,937,550
a
Yerramsetty and Murty (2008) 2,941,920 2,941,295
Lewin (1998) a 2,946,000 2,944,290
Bogataj and Kravanja (2012) a 2,771,000 2,944,689
Linnhoff and Ahmad (1990) 2,890,000 2,949,780
Myankooh and Shafiei (2016) a 2,889,617 2,956,648
Azeez et al. (2013) 2,976,000 2,963,013
Zhu et al. (1995) a 2,984,417 2,983,824
a
No stream split.
b
After revision, HUC1 and the split of H1 are deleted.

network was obtained by Pettersson (2005), using a sequential match
reduction approach based on an assignment model for the synthesis of
large-scale heat exchanger networks. The network has seven stream
splits and contains 15 independent variables. As is shown in Fig. 6.27,
the network is similar to a hyperstructure, and there is a sequential use
of hot utility for the cold stream C5. The revised TAC is 2,892,924$/yr.