Page 316 - Design for Six Sigma for Service (Six SIGMA Operational Methods)

284 Chapter Nine

Appendix A: Contradiction Table of Inventive Principles

What is deteriorated ? 1. Weight of movable object 2. Weight of fixed object 3. Length of movable object 4. Length of fixed object 5. Area of movable object 6. Area of fixed object 7. Volume of movable object 8. Volume of fixed object 11. Stress, pressure 13

What should be Improved? 9. Speed 10. Force 12. Shape
15 8 29 17 29 2 2 8 8 10 10 36 10 14 1 35
1. Weight of movable object
29 34 38 34 40 28 15 38 18 37 37 40 35 40 19 39
10 1 35 30 5 35 8 10 13 29 13 10 26 39
2. Weight of fixed object
29 35 13 2 14 2 19 35 10 18 29 14 1 40
8 15 15 17 7 17 13 4 17 10 1 8 1 8 1 8
3. Length of movable object
29 34 4 4 35 8 4 35 10 29 15 34
35 28 17 7 35 8 28 10 1 14 13 14 39 37
4. Length of fixed object
40 29 10 40 2 14 35 15 7 35
2 17 14 15 7 14 29 30 19 30 10 15 5 34 11 2
5. Area of movable object
29 4 18 4 17 4 434 35 2 36 28 29 4 13 39
30 2 26 7 1 18 10 15 2 38
6. Area of fixed object
14 18 9 39 35 36 36 37
2 26 1 7 1 74 29 4 15 35 6 35 1 15 28 10
7. Volume of movable object
29 40 35 4 17 38 34 36 37 36 37 29 4 1 39
35 10 19 14 35 8 2 18 24 35 7 2 34 28
8. Volume of fixed object
19 14 2 14 37 35 35 40
2 28 13 14 29 30 7 29 13 28 6 18 35 15 28 33
9. Speed
13 38 8 34 34 15 19 38 40 18 34 1 18
8 1 18 13 17 19 28 10 19 10 1 18 15 9 2 36 13 28 18 21 10 35 35 10
10. Force
37 18 1 28 9 36 15 36 37 12 37 18 37 15 12 11 40 34 21
10 36 13 29 35 10 35 1 10 15 10 15 6 35 35 24 6 35 36 35 35 4 35 33
11. Stress, pressure
37 40 10 18 36 14 16 36 28 36 37 10 36 21 15 10 2 40
8 10 15 10 29 34 13 14 5 34 14 4 7 2 35 15 35 10 34 15 33 1
12. Shape
29 40 26 3 5 4 10 7 4 10 15 22 35 34 18 37 40 10 14 18 4
21 35 26 39 13 15 37 2 11 39 28 10 34 28 33 15 10 35 2 35 22 1
13. Object’s composition stability
2 39 1 40 1 28 13 19 39 35 40 28 18 21 16 40 18 4
1 8 40 26 1 15 15 14 3 34 9 40 10 15 9 14 8 13 10 18 10 3 10 30 13 17
14. Strength
40 15 27 1 8 35 28 26 40 29 28 14 7 17 15 26 14 3 14 18 40 35 40 35
15. Duration of moving object’s 19 5 2 19 3 17 10 2 3 35 19 2 19 3 14 26 13 3
operation 34 31 9 19 19 30 5 16 27 28 25 35
16. Duration of fixed object’s 6 27 1 40 35 34 39 3
operation 19 16 35 38 35 23
36 22 22 35 15 19 15 19 3 35 35 38 34 39 35 6 2 28 35 10 35 39 14 22 1 35
17. Temperature
6 38 32 9 9 39 18 40 18 4 36 30 3 21 19 2 19 32 32
19 1 2 35 19 32 19 32 2 13 10 13 26 19 32 30 32 3
18. Illumination
32 32 16 26 10 19 6 27
19. Energy expense of 12 18 12 28 15 19 35 13 8 15 16 26 23 14 12 2 19 13
movable object 28 31 25 18 35 21 2 25 29 17 24
20. Energy expense of fixed 19 9 36 37 27 4
object 6 27 29 18