Page 320 - Design for Six Sigma for Service (Six SIGMA Operational Methods)

288 Chapter Nine

Appendix A: Contradiction Table of Inventive Principles
(Continued)

What is deteriorated ? 15. Duration of moving object’s 16. Duration of fixed object’s 19. Energy expense of movable object 20. Energy expense of fixed object 22. Waste of energy 23. Loss of substance 24. Loss of information 26. Quantity of substance

What should be Improved? 14. Strength operation operation 17. Temperature 18. Illumination 21. Power 25. Waste of time
26 10 19 35 16 2 14 16 6 16 6 10 35 28 27 10 19 35 20 4 34
21. Power
28 10 38 17 25 19 19 37 38 18 38 10 6 19
26 19 38 1 13 3 38 35 27 19 10 10 18 7 18
22. Waste of energy
7 32 15 2 37 32 7 25
35 28 28 27 27 16 21 36 1 6 35 18 28 27 28 27 35 27 15 18 6 3
23. Loss of substance
31 40 3 18 18 38 39 31 13 24 5 12 31 18 38 2 31 35 10 10 24
10 10 19 10 19 19 10 24 26 24 28
24. Loss of information
28 32 35
29 3 20 10 28 20 35 29 1 19 35 38 1 35 20 10 5 35 18 24 26 35 38
25. Waste of time
28 18 28 18 10 16 21 18 26 17 19 18 10 6 18 32 10 39 28 32 18 16
14 35 3 35 3 35 3 17 34 29 3 35 35 7 18 6 3 24 28 35 38
26. Quantity of substance
34 10 10 40 31 39 16 18 31 25 10 24 35 18 16
11 28 2 35 34 27 3 35 11 32 21 17 36 23 21 11 10 11 10 35 10 28 10 30 21 28
27. Reliability
3 25 6 40 10 13 27 19 26 31 35 29 39 4 40 3
28 6 28 6 10 26 6 19 6 1 3 6 3 6 26 32 10 16 24 34 2 6
28. Measurement accuracy
32 32 24 28 24 32 32 32 27 31 28 28 32 32
3 27 3 27 19 26 3 32 32 2 32 2 13 32 35 31 32 26 32 30
29. Manufacturing precision
40 2 10 24 28 18
18 35 22 15 17 1 22 33 1 19 1 24 10 2 19 22 21 22 33 22 22 10 35 18 35 33
30. Harmful action at object
37 1 33 28 40 33 35 2 32 13 6 27 22 37 31 2 35 2 19 40 2 34 29 31
31. Harmful effect caused by the 15 35 15 22 21 39 22 35 19 24 2 35 19 22 2 35 21 35 10 1 10 21 1 22 3 24
object 22 2 33 31 16 22 2 24 39 32 6 18 18 22 2 34 29 39 1
1 3 27 1 35 16 27 26 28 24 28 26 1 4 27 1 19 35 15 34 32 24 35 28 35 23
32. Ease of manufacture
10 32 4 18 27 1 27 1 12 24 33 18 16 34 4 1 24
32 40 29 3 1 16 26 27 13 17 1 13 35 34 2 19 28 32 4 10 4 28 12 35
33. Ease of operation
3 28 8 25 25 13 1 24 24 2 10 13 2 24 27 22 10 34
1 11 11 29 1 4 10 15 1 15 1 15 10 15 1 2 35 32 1 2 28
34. Ease of repair
2 9 28 27 13 28 16 32 2 32 19 34 27 10 25 10 25
35 3 13 1 2 16 27 2 6 22 19 35 19 1 18 15 15 10 35 28 3 35
35. Adaptation
32 6 35 3 35 26 1 29 13 29 1 2 13 15
2 13 10 4 2 17 24 17 27 2 20 19 10 35 35 10 6 29 13 3
36. Device complexity
28 28 15 13 13 29 28 30 34 13 2 28 29 27 10
37. Measurement or test 27 3 19 29 25 34 3 27 2 24 35 38 19 35 19 1 35 3 1 18 35 33 18 28 3 27
complexity 15 28 25 39 6 35 35 16 26 16 16 10 15 19 10 24 27 22 32 9 29 18
25 13 6 9 26 2 8 32 2 32 28 2 23 28 35 10 35 33 24 28 35 13
38. Degree of automation
19 19 13 27 18 5 35 30
29 28 35 10 20 10 35 21 26 17 35 10 1 35 20 28 10 28 10 13 15 35 38
39. Productivity
10 18 2 18 16 38 28 10 19 1 38 19 10 29 35 35 23 23