Page 97 -
P. 97

82     DUBINSKY,  HAZZAN,  TALBY,  AND  KEREN
                    Figure 6.6  Absolute and per-Module Number of Test Suites


                                                    Number of Test Suites
                                      130
                                      110
                                       90

                                       70
                                       50
                                       30

                                       10
                                            Feb  Mar  Apr  May  Jun  Jul  Aug  Sep
                                                    SpecP                SpecA

                                                    Test Suites per Entities
                                       2.1
                                       1.8
                                       1.5

                                       1.2
                                       0.9

                                       0.6
                                       0.3
                                           Feb   Mar  Apr  May  Jun   Jul  Aug  Sep
                                                      SpecP               SpecA



                      As the numbers indicate, any choice of normalization will produce biased results. For example,
                    on the one hand, normalization by the number of modules points “against” the agile project, since
                    it is more modular and therefore, it seems to have fewer tests per module. On the other hand,
                    normalization by the complexity metrics points “against” the plan-driven project, since it has a
                    higher complexity-to-size ratio, due to its higher ratio of free-text specifications.


                    Table 6.1
                    Ratio of Plan-Driven Versus Agile Project Measures (September 2005)

                    Number of modules                                       3.3
                    Size                                                    9.0
                    Keyword-based complexity                              11.0
                    Logic-based complexity                                13.3
   92   93   94   95   96   97   98   99   100   101   102