Page 143 - Big Data Analytics for Intelligent Healthcare Management
P. 143

136     CHAPTER 5 CHRONIC TTH ANALYSIS BY EMG AND GSR BIOFEEDBACK




                                                                                   Techniques, period
                    7.074
                 7  Subjects: 27                                                     EMGa, BaseLine
                                                                                     EMGa, 1 month
                                       6.000                                         EMGa, 3 months
                                      Subjects: 27                                   EMGa, 6 months
                 6
                                                                                     EMGa, 12 months
                                                    5.320
                    5.423                         Subjects: 25                       GSRa, BaseLine
                   Subjects: 26                                                      GSRa, 1 month
                 5                                                                   GSRa, 3 months
                                    5.115
                                  Subjects: 26                                       GSRa, 6 months
                                                              4.087                  GSRa, 12 months
               Aug. frequency  4                Subjects: 24  3.720
                                                            Subjects: 23
                                                 3.792
                                                            Subjects: 25
                                                                              2.913
                 3
                                                                            Subjects: 23
                                                                            2.714
                                                                           Subjects: 21
                 2
                 1
                 0
                      BaseLine     1 month      3 months     6 months    12 months
             FIG. 5.27
             Analysis of variation of frequency with duration.


                EMGa versus EMGv versus EMGav: Trend/Pattern Analysis of Groups undergoing EMGa
             EMGv and EMGav therapies over the experiment period of 12 months on the subjects for chronic
             TTH type headache for frequency, intensity and duration parameters is presented below.




             5.8.19 THE TREND OF AVERAGE OF FREQUENCY
             The Trend of Average of Frequency:
                The subjects underwent therapies of EMG with three variations: audio, video, and combined audio-
             video (Fig. 5.28).
                EMGav and EMGv: Both the therapies surprisingly started from the similar point of frequency of
             chronic TTH in the subjects with a starting frequency of 7.571 and 7.519, respectively. The improve-
             ment in reduction of TTH occurrence frequency to subjects is continuously increased for EMGav up to
             the end of the experiment but fluctuated for EMGv between 1 and 3months. For both the therapies,
             results reached 2.909 and 3.45 respectively with dropouts 5 for EMGav and 8 for EMGv. The higher
             dropout number in EMGv was a clear indicator that the therapy was not interesting, trustworthy, and
             reliable when compared to EMGav.
                Also, the improvement ratio was 1:0.593, which shows that EMGav was 112.5% better than the
             EMGv therapy.
                EMGa: From the above plots, one can easily conclude that EMGa showed drastic improvement in
             the rate of reduction from 7.074 to 2.913 over all other therapies used. The rate of reduction in chronic
   138   139   140   141   142   143   144   145   146   147   148