Page 301 - Handbook of Materials Failure Analysis
P. 301

6 Results and Discussion   297




                            70,000

                            60,000

                            50,000
                           Load (N)  40,000    Experiment

                            30,000
                                               Full model, elastic plastic
                                               Half model (nonlocal)
                            20,000             Half model (local)
                                               Full model (nonlocal)
                                               Full model (local)
                            10,000
                                0
                                  0      1      2      3      4      5      6
                                                    COD (mm)
                  FIGURE 12.10
                  Effect of symmetric boundary conditions on load-deformation behavior of a 1T CT specimen
                  (half vs. full model used in local and nonlocal FE analysis).






                                             Symmetry plane







                           Local model                         Nonlocal model
                  FIGURE 12.11
                  Crack growth path for a full 1T CT specimen (without symmetric boundary conditions, local
                  vs. nonlocal model).

                  symmetry are met. Hence, the results of the nonlocal model are more realistic when
                  compared to those of local model. Due to the above observation, one must be careful
                  about the use of local damage models for prediction of crack path when the geom-
                  etry, initial crack configurations, and loading conditions are complex.


                  6.5 EFFECT OF CRACK DEPTH ON THE PROBABILITY
                  OF CLEAVAGE FRACTURE IN THE DBTT REGIME
                  In the DBTT regime, the crack-tip experiences a large stress gradient and hence, the duc-
                  tilecrackgrowth(oftheorderoffewmicrons)beforeunstablecleavagefracturecannotbe
                  predicted by the local damage models. This is because of the mesh-dependent nature of
   296   297   298   299   300   301   302   303   304   305   306